Stick 'em in or take 'em out?

This is my favorite rescue hat that the hubby put in the Goodwill bag because it was his to get rid of causing me to say to him in horror..."What?!  You can't get rid of that!  I wear it ALL the time!"  Then I snatched it right out of the Goodwill bag and put it in the closet on my side.  But what I can never decide is this -

Ears IN or OUT???

Yes, these are exactly the kind of things that keep me up at  night.  So, how do you wear yours?

Pondering life's really small issues today,

~S